Nittany Cards Plus

Robert Hohn Edited 5 months ago

Awesome store, it was my first visit, and the employee's working (Hunter and Noah) were very friendly, knowledgeable, and professional...they have an amazing selection, with very fair prices on everything... They allowed me to browse for a long time, without making me feel rushed, which I appreciate a lot...Thanks for the good conversation, and teaching me a few things I didn't know as well guys. I highly recommend checking it out if you are into collecting sports and other similar products. I will definitely be back again, and they even gave me a generous discount on a large group of singles I purchased. Just wanted to say thank you again guys, it was very much appreciated.

Joy Johns 6 months ago

I was looking to get some non-sports cards graded and was assured over the phone that this location would absolutely be able to help me. When I made it up to the store today, the employee at the counter told me they "had to be sports cards". Disappointed with the wasted trip.

Christian Horn a year ago

Nittany Cards Plus is hands down the best sports card and memorabilia shop in central PA. The owner, Jason, is incredibly knowledgeable across all major sports, and his passion for the hobby shows every time I stop in. I buy from him frequently and often bring my kids along—it’s always a great experience, and Jason goes above and beyond to create a welcoming, customer-first environment. That’s something rare in today’s hype-driven card market. Jason is also very fair when buying cards. He’s generous with comps and always transparent, but it’s important to remember he’s running a brick-and-mortar business. Like any good shop owner, he needs to be selective with the inventory he takes in. If you come prepared—with reasonable comps from tools like 130point.com or recent eBay sales—you’ll almost always walk away with a fair deal or trade. It’s disappointing to see negative reviews from folks who expect full retail value for their cards without understanding the realities of the business. There are plenty of options to sell cards these days—don’t take it out on a local small business just because you weren’t prepared. Support your local shops. Nittany Cards Plus and Jason deserve eve

Rosie Spurlin 2 years ago

Great experience at this hobby shop! The parking lot is a little iffy when first coming in, but it’s handicap accessible with ramp. Wide selection of products that continues to grow. Opened in January 2024, so fairly new store as of now. Friendly owner/workers. Will buy/sell/trade. Appreciates the surrounding community and is kid friendly.

Christian Horn 2 years ago

My son and I have recently gotten into collecting football cards. I would consider us novices which makes Nittany Card Plus the perfect place for us to purchase our cards. Before Nittany Cards Plus we probably wasted time and money trying to get cards from Target or Walmart. The owner of Nittany Cards Plus (Jason) is so kind and knowledgeable. We are never pressured to buy. When we do stop in, we always find it a valuable experience!